Migrating to Minimally Annotated Models

References Cited

What is 3D Visualization?, What is MCAD?, Model Based Definition (MBD), Model Based Enterprise (MBE)

Studies Cited

The ROI of MBD Study

Developing 3D models with annotations isn’t the only improvement effort organizations are pursuing with respect to engineering documentation. Some are adopting practices to include the absolute minimum amount of annotations required in their deliverables. This means, for example, that a component that will be machined with toolpaths automatically created by a CAM software program with no manual programming will not require any annotations, theoretically. In contrast, if a sheet metal part requires the brake operator to manually set the bend dimension and angle, then that annotation should be included and displayed.

By pulling together the effort to minimize annotations and the effort to release a 3D model with PMI, some organizations are seeking benefits from both types of improvement efforts. The idea is to rely on the 3D model’s inherent geometry definition to convey the complete and detailed geometric form of a component while adding the minimal annotations to define the measures and thresholds within which a component meets quality standards.

This single reduced annotation deliverable fulfills all of the functions of engineering documentation with effort that, in theory, is lower. From a functional perspective, this deliverable is used in the same way downstream as a fully annotated 3D model, albeit with only the dimensions and tolerances that are needed for conformance measurements.

For the company, the benefits of a fully annotated model are realized here because there is a single unambiguous definition with a clear source authority for geometry and tolerance. There aren’t two definitions that can diverge, causing errors. Findings from this research report, as shared earlier, show a higher percentage of organizations releasing only MBD deliverables lower the number of change orders (30% vs. 21%) and reduce scrap (35% vs. 16%) by wide comparative margins as shown in Table 2.

Findings: Benefits of Migrating to Fully Annotated Models

Findings: Benefits of Migrating to Fully Annotated Models

Table 2: Comparison of benefits realized across the Model-Reliant and Model-Based cohorts. Details on calculations of the estimate, assignment of respondents into cohorts and the drawing datasets are detailed on The ROI of MBD Study page.

For the engineering organization, the flaw associated with fully annotated models, which according to estimates would take longer to create, is addressed. Findings from this research study show that the benefit associated with minimal or reduced annotation efforts carries over here. The amount of time estimated to create the minimally annotated model dataset averages 6.7 hours, less than the 8.8 hours estimated to create the fully annotated drawing dataset.

Finding: Time Saved in Migrating to Minimally Annotated Models

Finding: Time Saved in Migrating to Minimally Annotated Models

Figure 4: On the left is the average of the estimate to create the fully annotated drawing dataset by All Respondents cohort. On the right is the average of the estimate to create the minimally annotated model dataset by the Model-Based cohort. Details on calculations of the estimate, assignment of respondents into cohorts and the drawing datasets are detailed on The ROI of MBD Study page.

Furthermore, engineering organizations realize further advantages because such model-based deliverables require less interpretation. On average, organizations releasing MBD deliverables spend 20.7 hours per week on engineering documentation as opposed to 23.9 hours per week for organizations releasing drawings.

Finding: Time Spent on Engineering Documentation

Finding: Time Spent on Engineering Documentation

Figure 5: On the top is the average time per week that Drawing-Reliant organizations spend on engineering documentation. On the bottom is the average time per week that Model-Based organizations spend on engineering documentation. Details on calculations of the estimate, assignment of respondents into cohorts and the drawing datasets are detailed on The ROI of MBD Study page.

Overall, combining efforts to minimize or reduce annotation efforts with model-based deliverables provides validated benefits for the company, in the form of reduced ECOs and non-conformances, as well as less time spent by the engineering organization to create the deliverable.